Support This Website! Shop Here!

Saturday, January 10, 2026

Incommensurate Goals

Pope Leo recently argued "surrogacy reduces the child to a product, and of the mother, exploiting her body." This stance is so broadly based that even women who wish to adopt and rescue embryonic children abandoned to nitrogen freezers after IVF procedures are forbidden from doing so.

So, let's take the Pope's assertions and apply them to another source of social exploitation:

When a novice friar asked permission to own a psalter for study, Francis refused, warning: "When you have a psalter, you will want a breviary; and when you have a breviary, you will install yourself in a throne like a great prelate, and you will command your brother: 'Bring me my breviary!'"  ~ Speculum Perfectionis, St. Francis of Assisi 
If we wish to stop objectification that harms children and destroys families, then women's education arguably contributes to that result. After all, educating women violates and exploits women, reducing women to a product. That is, once women have been objectified by receiving education, they now become just a product of the marketplace.

Women, in turn, now treat their own future children as products. They weigh their possible future enjoyment of earnings from education against their possible future enjoyment of children, and generally choose the money over the child.

Once education turns a woman into a product, she turns her own children into a product. Statistics show that uneducated women have more children than educated women (1, 2). Each additional year of schooling drops women's fertility by up to 0.3 children, with college education dropping fertility by up to 40% (3, 4, 5).
"Let those who are illiterate not be anxious to learn to read, but let them pay attention to what they must desire above all else: to have the Spirit of the Lord and His holy manner of working, to pray to Him with a pure heart, to have humility..."
        ~Testament, St. Francis of Assisi
The evidence is quite clear: if we educate women (which the Catholic Church supports), then we destroy family formation and reduce the likelihood of women having children (which the Church opposes). It wants two diametrically opposed outcomes to result simultaneously from the same action. That is not possible.

If the Catholic Church truly wishes to stop the objectification of women and children at its source, then it should be pushing hard for everyone, everywhere to stop educating women.